by roving reporter Shaun Lawton (written without AI)
"I believe that if the development of physics has taught us anything,
it is that we must learn to think more subtly." Neils Bohr to Werner Heisenberg
After reading the article by Amanda Gefter called Reality Exists Without Observers? Boooo! that just appeared in issue 65 of Nautilus, and considering the quote at the end of it, from Bohr to Heisenberg, I thought, if I were to think more subtly about how to describe our observer-with-universe dynamic, I came up with the following description today:
A singularity in fluctuation
like an infinite cauldron
It's the best I could do, given the circumstances. Allow me to venture an explanation. The dilemma has been only exacerbated by our ordinary insistence to separate the observer from that which we observe, so it follows we should perhaps try to avoid that. What I got out of Amanda Gefter's article, is that contemporary physics has split into two interpretive camps. The Many Worlds view preserves objectivity by multiplication, proposing that every possible outcome occurs in a branching universe where nothing ever truly collapses. The Copenhagen interpretation, following Bohr, preserves coherence by limitation, refusing to describe reality apart from the conditions under which it is observed.
What follows here is my attempt to think more subtly still, while taking a lead from Bohr. I consider that reality remains something which somewhat branches out, yet does not collapse, and instead continuously engages us to participate—and not a collection of finished worlds, but an ongoing process in which distinction and observation arise and evolve together over time. In what follows, interconnection is not meant as metaphor, nor separation as illusion, but rather as functional aspects of reality—useful for navigation and survival. This distinction is not intended as an ontological denial of reality, but as a reminder that separation describes how we operate within the world, not how the world is ultimately composed.
Let's try an experiment that allows ourselves, with our brain's countless neurons and synaptic pathways, sending and receiving electrical and chemical impulses, in this mysterious and constant state of tracking our environment, to help us navigate through our complex continuum. Whether we are in the simple state of relaxing in a chair and reading a magazine, or at the steering wheel of an automobile going seventy miles an hour following the flow of traffic, driving home after work during rush hour, use that imagination we're allegedly in possession of (or potentially in a position which allows us to be possessed by it) and do our best to conceive of this notion. Consider the blood coursing through our veins as being part of us, just like we think how our limbs and fingers and bones are components which assemble into our unique individuality. Note how it follows that the electrical impulses flowing along our central nervous system and brain's intricate networks of axons pass along signals to stimulate the muscles of our arms and legs and feet and hands. See how this electrical flow remains analogous to the blood coursing through our veins and arteries. We understand there exists positive and negative ions down into the molecular and submolecular structure of our bodies, just as they do deep within the clothes we wear, and the cars we drive; not to mention the streets themselves, and trees as well as the ground of being here on this planet. We can easily surmise how this electrical current remains enmeshed throughout the entire tapestry of our world, extending from our bodies and beyond; indeed going further to connect as far as our Sun and its entire planetary system. For all we know, this electromagnetic webbing extends through all the gravitational wells threading through every star in our galaxy; connecting somehow farther than our current understanding, until it threads through all galaxies in a cosmic tapestry bound together by black holes, quasars and quantum forces which exist on a macrocosmic level our scientists have been marveling over and studying ever since the day we and all our ancestors were born.
It's not difficult to imagine; or to make it even more clear, we're not imagining it at all, but rather picturing the actuality of the total interconnection of our universe, which we like to think of as reality itself. Even while we can also imagine things that aren't real, like bat-winged unicorns with serpentine eyes and the chromatic scales of a dragon, let's not forget we've already invented a word for this, which is the word fantasy. Meanwhile, the reality of our existence remains obviously wholly interconnected together to the point we've dubbed another word for it; singularity. And even though many words can have multiple meanings, there are some whose meaning mostly has a singular definition, and this word, despite having a potential host of different applications to which it may be used, nevertheless also remains with its one initial meaning that could be ascribed to everything, in singular fashion, after itself. It's just that we're typically not occupied with this sort of conscious endeavor of thinking of everything, because we necessarily are focused on those aspects which we rely upon to navigate our way around a table, or getting into bed each night, so we may lay ourselves down to sleep and enter that mysterious state of rest that can bring dreams to mind.
We've become so accustomed to thinking of ourselves as separate from the rest of creation, that we don't usually give the matter much thought. If we did, we might start to come around to concluding that thinking such things may be more accurately described as an aberration, becoming more synonymous with the idea of fantasy, and we couldn't have that, because after all, we're hard wired to believe in reality, aren't we? Here's where the words we've become accustomed to start to shimmer and waver and become pliable, softening before our minds as if they were silly putty, only to be shaped into things temporarily, to lull us into a sense of false security, leading us toward the idea that this line of thinking simply will not do. Not when we have to rise up in the morning, dress ourselves once again, to put our shoes on, and tie our laces, and prepare breakfast and eat so we can have the energy to head out the door and get to work on time, or whatever it is we have on our daily agendas.
It's almost as if this condition we've come to think of as being hardwired remains some sort of default, automatic setting like a passenger jet having an autopilot. Yet if we stop for a moment and set aside whatever automated daily ritual we may be in the midst of, and think for a minute about how we are actually not just interconnected with the universe but integral aspects of it, sort of like the aforementioned scales on a reptile, well it can become disconcerting, to say the least. It's somewhat analogous to the curious phenomenon of how we rarely stop to think about the way we're constantly breathing. Yet consider this. In meditation, we are reminded of this connection to the universe, when we become consciously aware that we are in fact breathing, and then join in with creation by taking in deep breaths and slowly exhaling them, just a few in a row may be all we need to gauge that constant and rhythmic interconnection we have with nature, which after all remains all about us, in the form of the land and blue sky and the moon and everything that appears to lie beyond.
This exercise becomes one of the few times where we abandon fantasy altogether to become enraptured by the revelation that we may not be a part of everything so much as an inherent aspect of the entirety of creation itself. When we're welcomed into this reality, we liberate ourselves from being caught up in the trap of having falsely assumed we were separate from everything. Whether this may reveal we've been periodically lulled into thinking we're parts of a fantasy manifested in the ever so gradually fluctuating cauldron of eternity, I cannot say with any convincing degree of certainty, but I may offer a not uncommon insight that seems to feel right, when I think it aloud in my mind: The universe feels like it remains alive.
The Oscillating Oculus